On Cloud vs Brooks Running Shoes Comparison

Last Updated: January 25, 2024 | Author: Jake Thompson


While some may argue that brand loyalty should be the ultimate guide in choosing running shoes, I've learned that each runner's quest for the perfect shoe is as individual as their stride.

Brooks, a longstanding favorite, offers a wide range of comfortable, popular running shoes known for a cloud-like feel. Meanwhile, On Cloud, a newer brand is rapidly gaining popularity with its innovative design featuring cushioned pockets on the bottom, appealing to runners seeking both style and comfort.

On Cloud vs Brooks - hero

As a seasoned writer with a focus on athletic gear, I've come to appreciate the nuances that set On Cloud and Brooks apart. The former, with its Swiss engineering, promises a ride as light as air, while the latter boasts of a legacy in supporting runners with dependable, no-frills performance.

But what differentiates these brands and their top-performing models when the rubber meets the road? In the following lines, I will break down the technicalities of their flagship shoes, examining the intricate balance of function and form.


Table of Contents:

  1. Key Takeaways
  2. Table: Cloud vs Brooks Running Shoes
  3. Pros & Cons
  4. Brand Overview
  5. Construction and Design
  6. Performance
  7. Stability and Support
  8. Comfort
  9. Cushioning
  10. Breathability
  11. Durability
  12. Fit and Sizing
  13. Our Recommendations
  14. Final Verdict
  15. Frequently Asked Questions

Key Takeaways

  • - Brooks offers a wider variety of running shoe models for different foot types, training preferences, and shoe style needs compared to On Cloud.
  • - The durability of On Cloud vs Brooks running shoes is similar, with both brands recommending replacement after 300 to 500 miles of use.
  • - On Cloud shoes use CloudTec technology for cushioning, while Brooks utilizes different foam materials depending on the purpose of the shoe.

Table: Cloud vs Brooks Running Shoes

On cloud Brooks
Feature On Cloud Brooks
Brand Focus Newer brand, innovative design, and technology. A traditional, stability-focused, wide variety.
Fit and Feel Narrow fit, recognizable sole with pods. Wider toe box, accommodating fit.
Cushioning CloudTec technology, firmer midsole. Various foam materials, softer cushioning.
Weight Lightweight construction. Heavier, which can be advantageous for some.
Stability Focus on speed and reducing impact. GuideRails system for stability.
Design Modern, stylish aesthetics. More traditional, holiday-themed options.
Special Features Speedboard for energy return, unique outsole. Variety in midsole foams, focus on comfort.
Suitability Preferred for a firmer, responsive ride. Suitable for wider feet, and various foot conditions.

Pros & Cons

On Cloud Running Shoes

Pros:
  • - Innovative cushioning with CloudTec technology.
  • - Lightweight and responsive, ideal for speed.
  • - Stylish design suitable for running and casual wear.
  • - Comfortable with a soft landing experience.
Cons:
  • - May lack durability for diverse training.
  • - Narrow fit, not ideal for wide feet.
  • - Higher price range.

Brooks Running Shoes

Pros:
  • - Renowned for durability and longevity.
  • - Wide range of models for different needs.
  • - Excellent stability features, great for overpronators.
  • - Advanced cushioning technology for comfort.
  • - Accommodates wider feet well.
Cons:
  • - Some models are heavier, affecting agility.
  • - Traditional design, less fashion-forward.
  • - High-end models can be expensive.

Brand Overview

When examining the brand ethos of On Shoes vs Brooks, it's evident that both prioritize runners' needs but take distinct approaches to innovation and design in their footwear offerings.

As a seasoned analyst of running shoe brands, I've observed that On Cloud's signature technology, CloudTec, revolutionizes the way runners experience ground contact. This system employs hollow pods that compress under impact, promising a unique combination of soft landings and explosive take-offs.

Brooks, on the other hand, has carved out a niche in the stability running shoes segment with their DNA Loft cushioning. This plush, responsive material accommodates a variety of strides without compromising on comfort. Their focus on stability is evident in their dedication to maintaining a runner's natural gait rather than over-correcting it, which is a testament to their scientific approach to running biomechanics.

Both brands are formidable players in the running shoe game, yet they offer contrasting experiences. Brooks typically offers a more traditional running shoe structure with a pronounced heel drop, while On Cloud is synonymous with a minimalist, speed-enhancing design that appeals to athletes looking for a performance edge.

While discussing the brand ethos of On Shoes vs Brooks, it's interesting to note how Brooks models compare among themselves. For a deeper dive, check our comparison of Brooks Levitate vs Adrenaline, which sheds light on the nuances within the Brooks range.

Construction and Design

Delving into the construction and design aspects, it's clear that each brand employs distinct technologies and materials to enhance the runner's experience. Both brands have honed in on creating products that balance performance with comfort, though their approaches are quite different.

On Cloud's signature feature is its CloudTec technology. This is evident in the soles of their shoes, which include hollow pods that compress under impact for cushioning and then lock to form a solid base for a powerful push-off. The upper is typically made from a lightweight, breathable mesh that ensures a snug fit, while the midsole is designed to work in harmony with the CloudTec to provide a smooth ride.

Brooks, on the other hand, has its own proprietary cushioning called BioMoGo DNA, which adapts to the runner's stride, weight, and speed. The Guiderails system is another key feature, providing support by guiding the feet into proper alignment, which can be especially beneficial for runners with a tendency to overpronate. The upper design often includes a structured yet breathable mesh, and the heel-to-toe transition is crafted to be seamless and efficient.

Here's a quick rundown of their construction features:

  • - On Cloud: Lightweight mesh upper, CloudTec cushioning pods, responsive midsole
  • - Brooks: Adaptive BioMoGo DNA midsole, Guiderails holistic support system, structured mesh upper
  • - Heel Design: Emphasis on secure and comfortable heel fit
  • - Midsole Tech: Focused on providing a blend of cushioning and responsiveness

Performance

When assessing the performance of On Running vs Brooks shoes, stability and support become key factors in the evaluation.

I've observed that Brooks' GuideRails Technology offers a unique approach to stability, aiming to keep excess movement in check without over-correcting the runner's stride.

On Cloud's approach, with its emphasis on a lighter structure and the CloudTec system, focuses on a blend of cushioning and responsiveness to enhance performance without compromising on support.

Stability and Support

Both shoe brands prioritize accommodating a runner's natural gait rather than offering corrective structures in analyzing the performance aspects of stability and support. When it comes to stability running, a few key points stand out:

  • - Brooks GTS models are renowned for their stability and have been a staple for runners who overpronate.
  • - The shoes feature GuideRails technology, which acts to keep excess movement in check without over-correcting.
  • - On Cloud doesn't specifically target overpronation, but their shoes offer a balanced level of support.
  • - Brooks utilizes DNA Loft foam, providing a plush and stable ride for those who need a stability shoe.
  • - The concept of stability is approached differently by each brand, with a focus on natural biomechanics and runner comfort.

Comfort

When assessing comfort in Brooks vs On running shoes, there are two primary factors to consider.

Firstly, cushioning is a key aspect of comfort. On Cloud's CloudTec technology provides a distinct feel by utilizing hollow pods for impact absorption. On the other hand, Brooks employs various foam technologies for a tailored cushioning experience.

Secondly, the breathability of each shoe's mesh upper also plays a crucial role in comfort. This aspect influences temperature regulation and moisture management during runs.

Cushioning

While both On Cloud and Brooks offer shoes with notable cushioning features, they employ distinct technologies to achieve comfort for the runner. On Cloud utilizes their signature CloudTec system, with Helion super foam that's both light and responsive, giving a feeling of running 'like a cloud.' In contrast, Brooks features their DNA AMP cushioning, designed to provide a springy and energetic ride.

  • - On Cloud's Helion: Lightweight yet durable, it provides a softer, cloud-like sensation.
  • - Brooks' DNA AMP: Offers a responsive and bouncy feel, turning energy into forward motion.
  • - CloudTec Technology: Structured for high-impact absorption.
  • - EVA Foam: Used in various Brooks models for traditional cushioning.
  • - Cushioning Balance: Both brands strive for a cushion that offers both comfort and responsiveness.

Breathability

Moving beyond the cushioning technologies, it's essential to examine how these shoes perform in terms of breathability, a critical component of comfort during runs.

Both brands understand that a runner's experience is significantly influenced by how well a shoe manages moisture and heat. Typically, On Cloud shoes feature a breathable mesh upper that promotes air circulation, maintaining a cooler environment for the feet. Similarly, Brooks running shoes incorporate engineered mesh for breathability, ensuring a balance between airflow and structural integrity.

As a runner, I appreciate that these lightweight designs don't compromise on ventilation. Whether it's Cloud shoes or Brooks, the fusion of breathable materials in their running shoes features prominently to enhance overall comfort during extended periods of activity.

Durability

Assessing the durability of Brooks shoes vs On Cloud requires examining factors such as material quality, construction techniques, and user experiences to determine their longevity and performance over time. In my analysis, I'm considering these aspects meticulously, knowing that durability isn't just a perk, but a necessity in the running shoe world.

Here's what I've found:

  • - Material Quality: Both brands utilize high-grade materials, though Brooks shoes often incorporate more substantial overlays for added durability.
  • - Construction Techniques: On Cloud's unique CloudTec design presents both a resilient structure and a distinct underfoot feel, while Brooks focuses on traditional, reliable construction.
  • - User Experiences: Long-term feedback suggests satisfaction with the lifespan of both brands, with runners noting the rubber on the outsole holds up well.
  • - Wide Range of Shoes: Brooks offers a wide variety of models, with some designed specifically for durability in harsh running conditions.
  • - Performance Longevity: Durability doesn't compromise performance; both On Cloud and Brooks maintain their cushioning and support over many miles.

Both brands have invested heavily in ensuring their running shoes can endure the rigors of serious mileage. As a runner, I appreciate that whether I'm sporting a Cloud running model or a Brooks shoe, I'm lacing up with confidence, knowing they're built to last.

In assessing the durability of Brooks shoes vs On Cloud, it's also worth comparing different Brooks models. Check out our Brooks Adrenaline vs Glycerin article, highlighting how each model stands up in terms of longevity and performance.

Fit and Sizing

When considering the fit and sizing of Brooks vs On Cloud running shoes, it's crucial to note that they cater to different foot shapes and preferences, impacting a runner's choice significantly.

On Cloud vs Brooks - hero

Brooks typically offers a wider fit, particularly in the toe box, which can be a deciding factor for those with wide feet. Their shoe sizes are generally true to size, though some models may run slightly small, prompting a recommendation to go half a size up for optimal fit.

On Cloud, historically known for its narrower silhouette, has begun integrating models into its lineup that accommodate a broader range of foot widths. Despite this, individuals with especially wide feet may still find the fit to snug and might need to explore sizing options carefully or look for specific On Cloud models tailored to a wider foot.

Our Recommendations

Brooks vs On Cloud for Standing All Day

Brooks Ghost 15


The Brooks Ghost 15 shoes excel in providing all-day comfort for standing, thanks to their plush cushioning, supportive fit, and responsive BioMoGo DNA midsole. Their breathable mesh upper ensures feet stay cool and comfortable, while the durable rubber outsole offers reliable traction, making them ideal for prolonged standing.

Upper Material: Engineered mesh with 3D Fit Print.
Sole Material: DNA LOFT cushioning.
Outsole: Blown rubber.
Drop: 11mm.
Season: All-season.
Special Features: Segmented crash pad, Omega Flex Grooves, plush interior.
Size: Available in multiple sizes and widths for men and women.

ON Cloudflyer


The ON Cloudflyer stands out for all-day standing with its superior cushioning and stability. Its innovative CloudTec technology in the sole delivers soft landings and dynamic take-offs, reducing fatigue. The shoe's lightweight design, supportive structure, and breathable materials ensure enduring comfort and stability, ideal for extended periods on your feet.

Material: Engineered mesh with supportive midfoot structure.
Sole Material: Helion™ super foam for cushioning.
Outsole: CloudTec® rubber for grip and longevity.
Drop: 10 mm.
Season: All-season.
Special Features: Speedboard for energy return, stable cloud elements, lightweight design.
Size: Available in multiple sizes and widths for men and women.

On Cloud vs Brooks for Walking

Brooks Glycerin 20


The Brooks Glycerin 20 shines as a top choice for walking due to its exceptional comfort and support. Featuring DNA LOFT v3 cushioning, it offers a plush, responsive feel underfoot, ideal for long walks. The shoe's breathable upper and 3D Fit Print technology provides a secure, adaptable fit, while the smooth transition zone makes each step feel natural and efficient. Its durable outsole ensures reliable traction, making it excellent for various walking surfaces.

Material: Engineered mesh with plush interior lining.
Sole Material: DNA LOFT v3 cushioning for softness and responsiveness.
Outsole: Durable rubber for traction.
Drop: 10mm.
Season: All-season.
Special Features: 3D Fit Print technology, OrthoLite® sock liner, transition zone for smooth strides.
Size: Available in various sizes and widths for men and women.

For those considering the Brooks Glycerin 20 for walking, comparing it with other Brooks models can be insightful. See our Brooks Ghost vs Glycerin for a direct comparison to help refine your choice.

On Cloudmonster


The On Cloudmonster is excellent for walking, offering oversized CloudTec® elements for superb cushioning, Helion™ super foam for energy return, and a breathable upper for comfort. Its lightweight, durable design ensures a soft, responsive walk, making it a stylish and functional choice for those seeking comfort and performance.

Material: Recycled polyester mesh upper.
Sole Material: Helion™ super foam for maximum cushioning.
Outsole: CloudTec® with enlarged clouds for soft landings.
Drop: 6mm.
Season: All-season.
Special Features: Speedboard for energy return, monster Cloud elements, bold design.
Size: Available in multiple sizes for men and women.

On Cloud vs Brooks for Nurses

Brooks Adrenaline GTS 22


The Brooks Adrenaline GTS 22 is ideal for nurses, offering exceptional support and comfort during long shifts. Its GuideRails® support system ensures stability, while the DNA LOFT cushioning provides a soft, responsive feel. The breathable mesh upper and durable outsole make it perfect for the demanding environment of healthcare settings.

Material: Engineered mesh with 3D Fit Print.
Sole Material: DNA LOFT cushioning for a smooth ride.
Outsole: Blown rubber for durability and traction.
Drop: 14.7 mm.
Season: All-season.
Special Features: GuideRails® holistic support system, balanced cushioning, secure fit.
Size: Available in a variety of sizes and widths for men and women.

On Cloudflow


The On Cloudflow is highly suitable for nurses, offering responsive cushioning with its Helion™ superfoam, ensuring comfort during long hours. Its engineered mesh provides breathability and a snug fit, critical for busy shifts. The shoe's CloudTec® outsole delivers excellent traction and a smooth stride, ideal for the dynamic demands of nursing.

Material: Engineered mesh with adaptive weave technology.
Sole Material: Helion™ superfoam for lightweight cushioning.
Outsole: CloudTec® in Zero-Gravity foam for grip and durability.
Drop: 6mm.
Season: All-season.
Special Features: Speedboard for a responsive ride, antimicrobial treatment, and reflective details.
Size: Available in multiple sizes for men and women.

Final Verdict

In the comparison between On vs Brooks running shoes, the choice boils down to individual needs and preferences. On Cloud stands out for its lightweight, stylish design, and innovative CloudTec technology, making it ideal for runners seeking speed and a modern aesthetic. On the other hand, Brooks offers a more traditional, comfort-focused approach with a wide range of options, especially beneficial for those with wider feet or requiring more stability. Both brands excel in their respective niches, so the best choice depends on whether you prioritize a quick, responsive run or comfort and versatility in your running gear.

After deciding between On Cloud and Brooks based on your running needs, if you have specific foot conditions like accessory navicular syndrome, explore suitable shoe options in this guide on the best shoes for accessory navicular syndrome.



Frequently Asked Questions

1. Which brand, On Cloud or Brooks, offers a wider range of shoes for different types of running?

Both brands provide a diverse range of shoes catering to various types of running, including road, trail, and track. However, Brooks tends to have a slightly broader selection, especially for specialized needs like trail running.

2. Are On Cloud or Brooks shoes better suited for runners with wide feet?

Brooks is generally known for accommodating wider feet more comfortably. They offer a variety of models with wider toe boxes and options specifically designed for runners requiring extra width.

3. How do the sock liners in Brooks and On Cloud shoes compare?

Both brands offer high-quality sock liners designed for comfort and support. On Cloud's sock liners are often praised for their seamless and snug fit, while Brooks' sock liners are known for their plush cushioning and support, enhancing overall foot comfort during runs.

4. Which brand offers better trail running shoes, On Cloud or Brooks?

For trail running, Brooks often receives high marks for durability and traction, particularly with models like the Brooks Cascadia. On Cloud, while offering solid trail running options, is sometimes seen as more focused on urban and road running shoes.

5. What are the differences in cushioning technologies between Brooks and On Cloud?

On Cloud uses unique cushioning technology like their CloudTec® and Helion™ super foam, which focus on a lightweight, responsive feel. Brooks often employs EVA foam in their shoes for a traditional, plush cushioning experience. Their Hyperion line, known for its responsiveness and speed, combines innovative cushioning materials for a more performance-oriented run.



Share this:



Author Box
Jake Thompson

Jake Thompson

I am Jake, a sports enthusiast, love eveything about sports, particularly basketball and volleyball. I've played both sports at a local level. Here to share my passion for sports and sports gear experiences with you.